Pastry Gurl - Custom decorated cookies
Old-fashioned recipes baked in small batches from our kitchen to your local farmers market - Pastry Gurl brings you uniquely decorated cookies that taste like home. We service many areas including Crystal Lake, Marengo and Woodstock, IL.
Pastry Gurl Cookies are Perfect for:
Everyday treats to brighten someone's day
Special events and celebrations
Small meetings or corporate events
Hand-Crafted Sugar Cookies
This is a small sample of the many cookies we've created. As our site grows we will add more examples. Please let us know what you are interested in and we can design the perfect cookie for you.
Flavored Cookie Varieties
We also offer the following cookie varieties for sale at our market
Stop by and see what our "Flavors of the Day" are
-
Mom's Chocolate Chip
-
Pistachio Chocolate Chip
-
Peanut Butter
-
Oatmeal Raisin
-
Iced Oatmeal Raisin
-
Haystacks
-
Molasses
-
Sugar Cookies
-
Pecan Butter Cookies
-
Italian Butter Cookies
-
Almond Cookies
About our kitchen
There is something comforting about homemade cookies created with vintage recipes and simple ingredients like real butter, vanilla extract or the flavor of molasses. Whether rolled, scooped, or cut into shapes, these traditional treats remind us of home and family.
Our cookies are freshly baked and packaged in our home kitchen. Our baker is certified as a Serve Safe Manager and registered with the McHenry County Health Department. If you have any questions about our ingredients or flavors, please call or email us. We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Find Us at the Market
April 11, 2026 10 am - 2pm
Creative Arts Show
the Dole Mansion
401 Country Club Road
Crystal Lake, IL 60014
Coming soon to
Farmer's Market+At the Dole Mansion
401 Country Club Road
Crystal Lake, IL 60014
Cookie Order Request Form
Orders
If you would like to place an order, please complete the request form, and press submit. I will respond to you as quickly as I can.
-
There is a 12 cookie minimum for decorated cookie orders.
-
There is a 24 cookie minimum for flavor cookie orders
-
Orders are porch pick-ups in Marengo, IL unless other arrangements are made.
-
Please let us know if allergies to cookie ingredients could be a problem. (wheat, nut, dairy, etc. - cross contamination is a possibility no matter how careful we are)
-
Pastry Gurl will accept cash, Venmo or Zelle as payment. At this time we do not accept credit card payment.
Cookie Pricing
-
Individually packaged decorated cookies range from $3.50 to $4.00 each
-
There are price breaks for orders of 60 cookies or more
-
Decorated cookie size is approximately 4"
-
Flavored cookies start at $18.00 per dozen (Contact me via email or phone for more information)
Our cookies are produced in a home kitchen not inspected by a health department that may also process food allergens. If you have safety concerns, contact your local health department.
McHenry County Health Department Permit #2024-183 Marengo, IL 60152